Which one your company needs depends mostly on how many CDL drivers you have. Here is how to tell, and how the two options compare.
Last updated: November 17, 2026
If your company has only one CDL driver, and that driver is not leased to another motor carrier, you must use a consortium for random testing. If you have more than one CDL driver, you may run your own random pool, or you may still choose a consortium. Both routes can satisfy the rules. They differ in who does the work and who holds the records.
A consortium, formally a consortium/third-party administrator (C/TPA), is a service agent that manages all or part of an employer's DOT drug and alcohol testing program. For random testing, it combines drivers from many employers into one pool and selects from that pool.
FMCSA guidance requires an employer with only one CDL driver, such as an owner-operator who is not leased to a motor carrier, to place that driver in a consortium. One driver cannot be randomly selected from a pool of one, so there is no way to run the program alone. Read the agency's own explanation on the FMCSA owner-operator guidance page.
An employer with more than one CDL driver subject to DOT testing may manage its own random testing program. That means you are responsible for three things:
The governing rule is 49 CFR 382.305.
| Consortium | Your own pool | |
|---|---|---|
| Who it fits | Required for one-driver employers. Optional for larger fleets. | Employers with more than one CDL driver. |
| The pool | Your drivers are combined with other members' drivers. | Only your own drivers. |
| Who runs the draw | The consortium, on its schedule. | You, on your schedule. |
| Test rates | The consortium tests its pool at the required rates. | You track the rates against your own average pool. |
| Records | The provider holds selection records. You request them for audits. | You keep selection proof, timestamps and status history. |
| Control | Less. You depend on the provider's process. | More. You see every selection as it happens. |
| Cost | Fees set by the provider, which vary. | Your software and admin time. |
Either way, using a consortium does not remove your responsibility for compliance. You still need your drivers enrolled and your records in order.
DTSMS Online is built for employers who run their own random pool. It locks the pool, timestamps every selection, and keeps notification and status history together, so you can show an auditor exactly how a driver was chosen. If you are weighing the two routes, see how our random drug test selection software works, or compare plans.
Yes, in most cases. FMCSA guidance says an employer with only one CDL driver, such as an owner-operator who is not leased to another motor carrier, must place that driver in a consortium for random testing. A single driver cannot form a random pool alone.
Generally yes. FMCSA guidance says an employer with more than one CDL driver subject to DOT testing may manage its own random testing program. You then own the selection method, the notifications and the records.
For FMCSA-regulated drivers the 2026 minimum annual random rates are 50 percent of the average number of driver positions for drug testing and 10 percent for alcohol testing. These rates are announced each year, so confirm the current figures on the DOT ODAPC random testing rates page.
No. A consortium runs the random selections for its pool, but you still need every covered driver enrolled, tests completed after notification, and records you can produce in an audit. Treat the consortium as a service provider, not a replacement for your own oversight.
This page is general information, not legal advice. Official sources are listed beside the article.